Germany film school
1924
bw 88 min.
Director: F.W. Murnau
CLV: $49.95 - available
           1 disc, catalog # CC1378L
Rivaled only by Fritz
Lang and G. W. Pabst as Germany's greatest director of the silent age,
Friedrich Wilhelm Murnau was a tireless formal innovator exhilaratingly
difficult to pin down. If his 1922 horror epic Nosferatu represented an
apex of Expressionist sensibility, The Last Laugh was a heady synthesis
of trends shaping Weimar-era film and theater. Expressionist stylization --
surreal architecture, exaggerated shadowplay, nightmarish hallucination --
holds firm ground in The Last Laugh, but this landmark film is just as
much the product of a humanistic backlash against Expressionism's metaphysical
indulgences, inspired by the theater of Murnau's legendary mentor Max
Reinhardt.The Last Laugh tells a simple tale through intensely
subjective devices. A hotel doorman is forced by old age to trade in his
gold-buttoned paramilitary finery for a lavatory attendant's smock, falling
from graceful dignity to stooped humiliation in a peculiarly German warning
against the decline of benign authority. In contrast to the mechanical wonders
of the modern world surrounding him -- cars, trains, neon lights, elevators --
the porter, and his old-fashioned values, are outdated hulks. A son of rural
Westphalia, Murnau located terror in the countryside for Nosferatu; with
The Last Laugh, he places it in the city, its reflective surfaces
generating a frenzied kaleidoscope.
While Nosferatu's haunting effects
were accomplished through the imaginative use of previously established
techniques -- the phantom carriage ride to the vampire's castle, for example,
relied on stop-motion filming and the insertion of a few feet of negative into
the sequence -- The Last Laugh goes places no film had gone before.
Murnau had used panning shots in Nosferatu, and cameras had been moved
briefly off their tripods in a few other films, but this was the first time
that a mobile camera was thoroughly integrated into the production of a movie.
Murnau pulls no punches, thrusting the moving camera into the very first shot.
It descends to the hotel lobby in an open elevator, surveying the ant farm of
wealthy patrons below; traversing the lobby, it scoots forward -- resting atop
a bicycle steered by cinematographer Karl Freund -- to a set of revolving
doors, the rainy street, and bustling porter visible through the glass. For the
porter's drunken dream sequence, Freund strapped the camera to his chest (and
batteries to his back, for balance), stumbling around in mock inebriety to
capture a shot that lasts over a minute onscreen. The result is the birth of a
radically subjective cinema, plumbing the psyche of the porter and seeing the
world as his bewildered eyes do. The camera practically becomes a character in
itself -- actors can actually be seen trying to keep out of its way.
The
Last Laugh is also a bold experiment in narrative, completely -- with one
significant exception -- eschewing intertitles. (Original German prints had
about 15 intertitles, still vastly fewer than the norm, though their provenance
has been questioned.) Combined with the moving camera, the absence of title
breaks allows for a stunning fluidity of visual expression, the actors guiding
the story through pantomime. As the porter, Emil Jannings is at once hypnotic
and overbearing in one of the key roles of his career, so graphically agonized
by his downfall that his slumped, semi-catatonic figure can be painful to
watch.
Some critics gave much of the credit for The Last Laugh's
technical and stylistic innovations to Carl Mayer, Germany's signal
screenwriter of the era (he also co-wrote The Cabinet of Dr. Caligari).
The moving camera, for instance, had previously been used in Sylvester,
written by Mayer and directed by lesser light Lupu Pick. Mayer had first
eliminated intertitles in Scherben, another collaboration with Pick, who
was slated to direct and star inThe Last Laugh until he and Mayer had a
falling out. Mayer conceived The Last Laugh as part three of this trilogy,
each film a fierce post-Expressionist foray into the trough between the old
world and the new. As Freund praised the writer's cinematic instincts, "A
script by Carl Mayer is already a film."
The film's ending was one originally
planned by Mayer. The one intertitle introduces "quite an improbable epilogue,"
a sequence jarringly different in sensibility from anything preceding it. Film
historians believe it was the result of pressure from the UFA studios, while
Jannings claimed in his autobiography that he had personally requested a new
ending. The Last Laugh, the title chosen for the film's American
release, reflects the upbeat coda; the original German title was Der Letzte
Mann, or The Last Laugh, characterizing the porter adrift in the
revolving-door chaos of the modern world (and cribbing a phrase from
Nietszche's anxious take on modernity). Whatever his directives, Murnau plays
the epilogue as belabored farce, a grotesque parody of a happy ending that can
easily be mistaken for the real thing. And it most probably was: based on the
film's national success, William Fox brought Murnau to Hollywood.
Not
surprisingly, the strictures at Fox dwarfed those Murnau had faced in Germany.
After making two and a half of the four movies in his contract (including the
classic Sunrise), he cut loose for Tahiti, where he composed the
anthropological spectacle Tabu. Disregarding his subjects' warnings,
Murnau built a bungalow on sacred ground; his death in a California car
accident a week before Tabu's premiere remains as much of an enigma as
his life. With much of his early German work now lost and the films of his
future unmade, each work by Murnau is a tantalizing piece of a beautiful
puzzle. His overarching intentions, however, were always sparklingly clear: he
wanted the fledgling film medium to have a language all its own. "Our whole
effort," he told Motion Picture Classic magazine upon his arrival in the
U.S., "must be bent toward ridding motion pictures of all that does not belong
to them . . . the tricks, gags, 'business' not of the cinema, but of the stage
and the written book. That is what has been accomplished when certain films
reached the level of great art. That is what I tried to do in The Last
Laugh."
-- Alyssa Katz
CREDITS
Directed by: F. W.
Murnau
Produced by: Erich Pommer
Screenplay by: Carl Mayer
Director of
Photography: Karl Freund
Art Direction by: Robert Herlth, Walter
Ršhrig
Original score composed by: Giuseppe Becce
New score composed and
conducted by: Timothy BrockTRANSFER
The Criterion Collection is
proud to present The Last Laugh in a version that has not been seen in
this country since its original 1925 American release. Director Murnau and
cinematographer Karl Freund shot multiple takes of each scene and composed at
least two complete negatives of the film. This version, unearthed by film
historian and restorer David Shepard, is longer than the one familiar to modern
audiences. The new transfer was made at 20 frames per second from a
full-aperture nitrate negative.